Sotnikova’s golden score gasoline figure skating controversy
SOCHI, Russia – Elvis Stojko ended up being prepared. It actually was times following ladies Olympic figure skating opposition, and Stojko got reveal lead layer available. He began to tick down, element by aspect, precisely why the guy believe Adelina Sotnikova of Russia earned to conquer protecting champ Yuna Kim of Southern Korea and Carolina Kostner of Italy.
“Adelina emerged filled,” Stojko mentioned. “performed one other two have significantly more breathtaking skating? Absolutely. But it is a sport, and also this was actually entirely reasonable.”
It had been no real surprise that Stojko, a two-time Olympic silver medalist from Canada noted for his athleticism, have these types of an opinion about a results certain to be being among the most shady and debated in figure skating’s checkered judging record.
His opinion that Sotnikova had earned her surprwase victory Thursday according to the https://besthookupwebsites.org/friendfinderx-review/ math of the scoring system, adopted after the 2002 pairs skating scandal, was shared by several other former skaters, including some known more for their artistry and style, such as Olympic medalists Philippe Candeloro of France and Paul Wylie of the U.S.
“I don’t have an issue with the effect, besides the (margin) from it,” Wylie mentioned. “The objectives were these people were gonna crown king Yuna one last time, once it don’t arrived at go, it’s like, ‘exactly how did that take place?’ “
But also they had questions regarding the judging, which smelled of room preparing to sate a roaring Russian audience within Iceberg Skating Palace
Sotnikova, 17, ninth in a year ago’s world championships, became their nation’s earliest Olympic ladies’ singles champ by 5.48 factors over Kim. The Russian’s blend of large jumps, rate and power generated the case for strengthening that margin when you look at the technical markings, therefore directed the judges getting carried away so she did not drop it from the ingredient results.
“The scores receive from the judges,” Kim said. “I’m not in proper place to comment on they. Nothing is which will change using my words.”
A week ago, 2010 Olympic winner Evan Lysacek from the U.S. got wondered whether Kim’s diminished a multiple circle hop into the complimentary skate might harmed the lady. That showed prophetic: Kim did six triple leaps, Sotnikova seven, and also the 7th ended up being a triple cycle for which the Russian attained 6.7 factors.
Sotnikova complete with points to for Kim. Kostner got next at . The three had opted into the free of charge skate divided by lower than a place.
“possibly Yuna failed to see sufficient things inside the short program simply because they did not should duplicate exactly what have happened in Vancouver, in which we knew prior to the cost-free skate who was probably winnings,” Candeloro mentioned.
S. ended up being last, with teammates Ashley Wagner and Polina Edmunds seventh and ninth, respectively. The U.S. women went without a medal in successive Olympics the very first time since 1948.
Russia’s Yulia Lipnitskaya, 15, that has be an international experience on her behalf brilliant skating in the staff occasion, dropped in singles applications and finished 5th.
Canada’s Jamie purchase, which obtained a sets silver medal from the 2002 Olympics after a French judge accepted she ended up being pushed to correct the end result and only deal’s triumphant Russian opponents, tweeted she have just seen the women’s cost-free skate once more and “we STRONGLY DISAGREE w/results like other others. #ISU now what?”
The worldwide Skating Union has generated a rating program so mathematically intricate, truly incomprehensible. In addition to that, it allows judging and technical sections to have substantial issues interesting (one assess on Thursday’s section, Alla Shekhovtseva, try partnered into former Russian Skating Federation president) you need to include cheaters (another judge, Yuri Balkov of Ukraine, was dangling for their part in prejudging an event).
Joannie Rochette of Canada, the 2010 women’s bronze medalist, discovered Thursday’s benefit “weird” but wouldn’t normally touch upon the evaluator because she was, like many fans, simply confused.
“I becamen’t positive we realized because I read such top quality in Yuna, and I see a new woman in Adelina with unrefined moments,” Browning stated. “But I found myself smart sufficient to operate and look at the scars before we stated such a thing.”
Gracie Silver regarding the U
Browning watched clear details for precisely why Sotnikova’s technical scars comprise 5.85 information better than Kim’s, like the South Korean obtaining reduced base beliefs on a spin and a footwork sequence. What perplexed your is how Sotnikova’s part results Thursday might be nearly nine guidelines raised above the lady typical ingredient score in four earlier games this season.
Sotnikova made one tiny technical error, a two-footed getting on the 3rd leap in a mixture, which is why she was penalized.
“I happened to be waiting around for the mistakes she usually makes, and she never produced all of them,” mentioned 1984 Olympic champ Scott Hamilton, commenting for NBC.
“we looked at the way the aspect get (policies) include created, and Adelina inspections off every container. It’s not as aesthetically pleasing as Yuna or Carolina, but she does everything the evaluator require.”
Sotnikova’s cost-free skate showed more elegance than this lady helter-skelter quick system, even when she hammed it right at the end with a revolution within evaluator. They recognized by using the second-highest no-cost skate get ever sold.